Fox River Dam Task Force Advances Consultant Selection Amid Public Concerns

Introduction

The Fox River Dam Joint Task Force convened on February 7, 2025, to review progress on consultant selection for engineering and environmental studies while gathering public input on dam removal impacts. The 50-minute meeting highlighted concerns from residents regarding property values, environmental health, water levels, and tax revenue. Updates from the Illinois Department of Natural Resources (IDNR) and the Army Corps of Engineers underscored the complexity of the process, as the Task Force reaffirmed its fact-finding role.

Consultant Selection Process Moves Forward

Narrowing the Field

Seven consultant firms initially submitted Statements of Interest (SOIs) to provide engineering and environmental services for the Fox River Dam project. After a thorough review by the SOI committee—comprised of city staff, task force members, and park district representatives—three firms were selected as finalists.

The next steps include refining the Request for Proposal (RFP) to focus on time-sensitive data such as river flow rates and water quality. The RFP will be sent to the finalists with a 30-day turnaround period, and a consultant is expected to be chosen by the next meeting.

Evaluation Criteria

Key factors in selecting a consultant include:

• Proven competency and qualifications

• Ability to collaborate with local entities

• Understanding of the Fox River’s environmental and recreational context

Public Voices Strong Opinions on Dam’s Future

Property Value Concerns

Riverfront property owners voiced apprehension that dam removal could negatively affect property values, impacting both homeowners and city tax revenues. These economic considerations were confirmed to be part of the consultant’s evaluation scope.

Environmental and Recreational Implications

Residents expressed mixed opinions on the dam’s ecological role. Some argued that removal could restore river health, while others emphasized the benefits of the existing lake-like environment for fish species, boating, and tourism.

Water Levels and Groundwater Impact

Concerns were raised over how dam removal could affect water levels and potentially impact shallow wells. While not part of the initial study, the Task Force confirmed the City Council could expand the consultant’s scope to include groundwater studies.

Energy Potential

Suggestions were made to explore energy generation through hydroelectric turbines at the dam as a sustainable alternative to full removal.

Updates from IDNR and Army Corps of Engineers

Federal and State Timelines

The Army Corps of Engineers’ environmental assessment timeline has been delayed, with no new binding date announced. The federal review process is expected to take three to four years, assuming no litigation.

The Illinois Department of Natural Resources, which owns the dam, has entered the design phase of the study. IDNR indicated that if the community fails to make a timely decision, it is prepared to move forward with removal.

Task Force’s Role and Public Involvement

The Task Force reiterated its role as a fact-finding group, emphasizing that final decisions rest with the City Council. Members encouraged residents to review the initial RFP and submit feedback to ensure all relevant questions are addressed. Citizens were also urged to contact elected officials directly to voice opinions on the project.

Next Steps

To allow time for consultant responses and information gathering, the next Task Force meeting is scheduled for April 3, 2025. By then, the group expects to have significant progress on consultant selection and a clearer project timeline.

Conclusion

The February 7, 2025, Fox River Dam Joint Task Force meeting underscored the high level of public interest and complexity surrounding the dam’s future. With consultant selection underway and diverse community perspectives on the table, the coming months will be critical for gathering accurate data and shaping recommendations. The Task Force remains committed to transparency, encouraging active public involvement in this pivotal decision-making process.